By the time she arrived at the hospital, Spencer was in surgery and all Rudee could do was wait and hope her friend would pull through. While there's always been lots of chatter about Diana being a "commoner . Before she married Jimmy Grund she was married to Tom Whited Sr. She beat her stepson's so bad he is now mentally retarded. How late could she stay out? The methods were transformative, I use them to this day. Lucinda Gayle Williams (born January 26, 1953) is an American singer-songwriter and a solo guitarist. Thats why I really needed to meet Lucas.. Woman killed in Louisville after being struck by tree limb during windstorm. April 18, 2018. We talked about it while we worked. Karl said the last time Bobby Stout had been there was a year and a half ago. Because my dad wasnt there when she got there. It was like it helped to release something.. He he kind of broke down one time in the hospital and said something. It had even turned brother against brother. She even gave fans several glimpses of what happens between takes on the program in pictures posted on Instagram. What Clay doesn't realize, however, is that Lucinda isn't nearly as nice as she looks and he soon gets more trouble than he could ever hope to realize. The next morning, Stout changed his story somewhat. Like his uncle David, he was trying to stay neutral. How about an ambulance? Midnight. The deck had been stacked against her from the beginning. She added that all the business affairs of the Stout household were handled by Sharon, not Bobby. Rudee got the call and rushed to the hospital as she tried to get a hold of Spencers family out of state. Some time after midnight. To kill them, Anna said. They hoped that voice would be 18-year-old Robert Stout, Lucindas brother, but David Lancaster didnt like the look on Roberts face when he saw him coming out of the courthouse mens room with his father. Sir, my mother, I assumed, was dead because she wasnt breathing. But Gaither couldnt resist pounding home a few more points. Robert had been working for his father at the time the crimes were committed. Though Robert had looked stunned and ashen when he came out of the mens room, Lancaster had to take a chance on him. #cowx pic.twitter.com/FAxsrZ5DFX, NWS Boulder (@NWSBoulder) April 17, 2018. In those weeks Rudee got to know the man who was beside her friend in her last moments, and the two became friends in their own right. She is still pretty, with large dark eyes and delicate hands. Ben Spencer hugs his mother, Lucille Spencer, after he was released from the Dallas County jail in Dallas on Friday, March 12, 2021. Lancaster moved on. 11lb. Join Facebook to connect with Lucinda Spencer and others you may know. Her testimony, after all, was more important than Bobby Stouts. By what name was Vows of Deception (1996) officially released in Canada in English? The Moving can be an exciting experience. Numerous trees have been uprooted, many people are without power, and roads have been closed due to vehicles being blown over. photo: Danny Clinch. Most mornings, the girl is up at dawn. While investigators initially thought it might have been a fall, the coroners office ultimately ruled the cause of death heart disease. Thats all he could talk about, that it should have been him and not her, Rudee said. Lucinda Stout took the stand to a packed house. Police officers George Kleinmeir, Jeff Hinkle, and David Kunkle recreated the circumstances surrounding Lucindas confession. I would. One of them would add that she was an incurable sociopath, likely to commit further violent acts. She wanted me to come home with her because she didnt want to do it by herself. No moments but puckering and prancing about in revealing costumes too tight and too small for her. She was just getting to know her neighbors.. Were they preparing for a party the next day? Julian Clark said at the time. An enormous part of the tree had fallen and hit Cinda they were sitting two feet apart and it missed him entirely but hit her pretty directly on, " Dan said as he walked over and pointed to the area where it happened. Sharon had been stabbed to death; Bobby had been shot with a .38. Lancaster objected to the last as hearsay and bolstering supporting the statements of an unimpeached witness with second-hand knowledge. Then Thursday was the day it happened.. I spent time on the phone talking to his mom afterward, getting to share all of the experiences I had with him. A bit later he heard a banging at the back door. When your father got back, did he have someone with him? . Lucinda testified that she had stayed overnight at Anna Villasanas the Tuesday before the murder. Lancaster shifted gears. Lucinda said she then walked over and kicked the knife out of her fathers reach. Im not going to take the blame. "Right now, there is no one to vent that anger towards," JeromeStrange said. In a bag, the police officer replied. We feel like he was a hero even though (Spencer) died. Then Lile heard the sound of wood snapping. "She didn't always have an easy life but that vulnerability she turned into an ability to just touch other people and we've been meeting so many different friends here and the way they speak about what she meant to them, means a lot to us," said Dan. Likewise, her beauty definitely added to the overall scenery as well. "Lucas held her and comforted her, as far as we know I don't think she ever regained consciousness but we were comforted knowing she was being held in those last moments.". Its in the old part of Louisville, Louisville police Sgt. Although KSP said the case has been cold for years, investigators would still like to speak with anymore who has information about what happened March 25, 1990, in Bardstown, Kentucky. When he relayed Williams' symptoms . Yes, sir. She says she still hasnt pieced together the agony of two years ago because there are some things that take time to understand. Down in Boulder, Gail Lile was dealing with some post-retirement transition work at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration when she got a call from her husband Larry Lile. You killed one and now you want to put it on your dad . When Alexanders turn came to cross-examine, he found that for one of the few times in his career, he was genuinely angry with a witness. Assistant District Attorney Hal Gaither found the Stout case a challenge to the imagination: Daughter stabs mother, shoots father. Its not as bad as it looks on TV, she says. Since Shawn had exposed them, Anne Dudek's Psych character had to be transferred. I was very grateful to be with her, Rudee said. I felt like I had to be strong and tell him you have to move on.. No, sir. Lancaster redirected: Did the testing indicate anything that would lead you to believe that she would be a sociopath? I dont understand. Did you ask her if she wanted an attorney with her when she answered your questions? Yeah, Im finished. Record warmth then pop up storms in the evening. Dont you know how you breathe? Spencers battle was over. He was just a very dedicated man.. He didnt tell me anything. Look at her, Daddy, Lucinda said. Its in the old part of Louisville, Louisville police Sgt. In the days that followed, Lara shared photos at physical therapy, working out with an exercise ball and doing leg and ab stretches. Theyre acquainted; theyre not real good friends. And you told me that you didnt remember enough about your conversation with Lucinda to truthfully say what you remembered, didnt you? It is a term to describe individuals who have an absence of conscience, tend to blame others for their conduct, and have a high need for self-gratification. Although I didn't expect too much initially due to the made-for-television format, I was somewhat surprised by how well it kept my interest pretty much from start-to-finish. The scene at his brothers house in northwest Dallas was like a grotesque carnival: Red patrol car lights swept the neighborhood; two-way radios squawked and sputtered; patrolmen prowled the yard while neighbors stared and whispered across the street. Bobby Stout said he and Sharon had been married in 1958, when she was 14, he 16. When Lancaster had seen her sitting in one of the prosecutors offices, he had known it would do no good to put her on the stand. Yes, she did. Since June 10 and 11, have you been afraid of what she might do if she was released? She said shed gotten in trouble with her parents because she didnt get up the next morning and go to work. Then, before Lile headed out, he told Puzo he wanted to tell her about something. But in the spring of 2018, they found themselves at similar places in life. She attended school in the Clairton School District and. , she has been keeping her foot elevated. Letters: Proposed age limit for gun ownership in Colorado doesn't make sense, Skygazers will have a great view Wednesday of two planets that look like they are almost touching, Multiple Colorado schools temporarily placed under secure status due to threats, Woman shot near CU Boulder overnight, suspect is at large, In 4 years, Lori Lightfoot went from breakout political star to divisive mayor of a Chicago beset by pandemic and crime, Florida lawmakers to consider expansion of so-called dont say gay law, Drone crashes at Disneyland after hovering over visitors heads See video, Rapper Travis Scott wanted for assaulting Manhattan club sound engineer, destroying $12K in equipment, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. I dont agree with his opinion. Before he went back to work for the county, Lile had one more job. Lucinda was monitored regularly by her godfather, Spencer Harrison, who gave her everything that she wanted to make sure she stayed distracted from her family. He was quiet, he didnt go anywhere, that wasnt like him. Were you getting up or were you lying down? Lancaster was glad he didnt have to make final arguments until the morning. The blood on one of the knives matched Sharon Stouts. you thought you were going to be in charge of his financial affairs at this time, didnt you? I just thought she had been hit by a car.". Did 1 ask you if Lucinda told you that she was going to kill her parents and you said no, didnt you? Father turns on daughter; daughter turns on father. She helped him with the bookkeeping at his business after she got off work at the bank. By implication, they were raising an even larger question: Can a juvenile be arrested under one set of privileges and then tried and convicted under another? Lucinda said she then went to her room. A favor to a friend had turned into six months of the toughest criminal work hed ever done, for a court-appointed attorneys fee of $3,000. He just said nobody was going to hurt me or anything. I was. I have a life-long interest in nature conservation, as well as a strong public service background. . She had been stabbed 40 times. Spencer and Lile were taking a break from moving, standing outside near a tree, something Rudee said they did often. Copyright 2023, D Magazine Partners, Inc. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. When he was telling me about what happened, he looked up after he heard the crack of the tree and shes bleeding, Gail Lile said. Well, how? You have a lot of older trees in the area. Stouts testimony had been convincing at the certification hearing, but that was before a judge, not a jury. He further said that about a month after he had gotten out of the hospital, his father had a picture of Angela Creed on the desk in his office. . No, said Robert, looking down. We feel like he was a hero even though (Spencer) died. By coincidence, Liles service and Spencers wound up being on the same day. Lile hadnt come back from a job up the trail. Ill get you help. LOUISVILLE, Colo. The Boulder County Coroners Office on Thursday identified the woman killed by a falling tree limb during Tuesdays wind storm. He had never before certified a juvenile. What kind of club is the Jet Set International? Just two unfortunate, but unrelated deaths. David Lancaster hated to admit to himself how much he needed those breaks. I told him that I was going to do what he said and that 1 loved him. Birth date listed as July 15, 1979 on a marriage certificate on-screen in May 2011 Believed to have perished in a fire on April 23, 1999 Occupation Former detective for the Port Charles Police Department Former photographer for Deception, Inc. Resides At Ireland Formerly 24 Royal Street, Port Charles, NY Are your dad and Harry Stout good friends? Did you and your wife ever discuss a girl named Angela Creed? Lancaster asked once the jury had left the room. As a long-time defense attorney, David Lancaster knew a thing or two about Grigson. Her sister Terry knows all about her case and the complexes of it, and her revelation brings the key to the picture. Nearly three decades later, JeromeStrange hopes the next call he receives will be the one he's been waiting for one where investigators tell him an arrest has been made in the case. Spencer is the upcoming biographical drama from Jackie director Pablo Larran. Police never found the killer. After the session, he went for another test. This objection was based, in part, on a landmark decision by Dallas Federal District Judge Robert Porter last year. For her it is an example of how not everyone knows the impact they can make on others lives, or how people can become joined by fate. Lara is a mom to kids Duff and Katharine, whom she shares with her ex-husband, David Haffenreffer. Learn more about merges . On my return back from Mat leave I was lucky to find a new employer who. Luanda Stout had called her friend Anna Villasana after the crime, but neither Lucinda nor Anna could remember what Lucinda said on the telephone. Davids brother Bobby had been almost fatally wounded, and was in surgery to remove two .38 slugs. Puzo oversaw its installation last fall in memory of her friend. Its been quite a long time. And what did Lucinda say later that night when she called? The only motive she offered the police was that her parents had grounded her for two weeks and she was angry because of it. Good Morning America host Lara Spencer is on the mend after undergoing surgery at the start of 2023. He felt so bad because he couldnt save her. Let her answer the question, Judge Mead responded. Did she tell him why she did it? Not that I can remember. The next day we heard she had died, and that set him back again, and he felt so bad. A few days later, in an attempt to even the score, he asks Lucinda to appear at a gathering as a blind date for Clay and then surprising him by removing her overcoat. And there he is holding her in his arms and then helping me and the family., The fact that he died is hard to understand. Love Island 2021 contestants Lucinda Strafford and Aaron Francis have ended their romance only days after leaving the villa. To a politically astute prosecutor like Wade, the message was clear: Bring the hammer down on juveniles. David Lancaster went back over the facts. David Lancaster had wanted to do what was right for Lucindas appellate chances, and it was a fact that he was dog tired the evening he had to argue Lucindas case. . I can't put weight on my left leg for five more weeks if I am lucky and even then, will still be wearing this boot for another five BUT I can stay in shape in the meantime, the ABC News correspondent captioned a January 11 workout video. Lucinda Stout is the first adolescent female to be certified to stand trial as an adult in the countys history. One judge may be satisfied that a child is beyond rehabilitation on the basis of one or two psychiatric reports; another may want ten. The Boulder County Coroner's Office on Thursday identified the woman killed by a falling tree limb during Tuesday's wind storm. News4's Jackie Bensen reports. What else did she have to do? Not long after David Stout arrived, they carried out Sharons body in a blood-stained canvas bag. Be that as it may, while certainly not a great crime-drama by any means, I found it to be a decent movie for the most part and I have rated it accordingly. Officers were sent to a domestic on Walker Street after neighbors called 911. Barely a week before the certification hearing, the DAs office filed a motion to have him removed from the case. Lawyers in Dallas know that there are two kinds of homicides: Murder and The Big M. Big Ms make the front page, while murders wind up in the obits. . They have the right to demand that an adult a parent, guardian, lawyer, or juvenile officer be present. He dug out his Superman lunch box, and went to start work the next day. Then he was shot in the back and fell to the floor. They hadnt pled temporary insanity, justifiable manslaughter or self-defense in the stabbing of Sharon Stout; theyd simply asked the jury to believe the daughter instead of the father. Lucindas probation officer testified that Lucinda had been cheerful, helpful, and hard-working during her stay at the juvenile detention center. Here is a summary of the highest gusts. She decided that she was going to kill them, and she said Anna, dont you see that if I run away I would be poor and wouldnt have anything. First published on April 20, 2018 / 10:01 PM. Did he hear Bobby Stouts testimony? Was possible life imprisonment the States best response to a case in which a girl had allegedly stabbed her mother to death and shot her father? Lancaster was ready for Anna. Intellectually, she was in the superior range. "Spencer" is a psychological thriller about a. She showed off a sweet gesture by her husband, Rick McVey, after he went out to get her breakfast on January 14. This theory is based on the idea (for which I have no evidence) that Lucinda was secretly an unstable psychopath. "I always dream of getting a call from state police, that they're gonna make an arrest," Jerome Strange says. On May 10, 2018, Puzo was out in the field at Heil Valley Ranch when she saw people rushing to the other side of the ridge, gathering at the main trailhead. It is a very straightforward, very classical case. The appeal of Lucinda Stout was turned down only two months later. How much money have you made from the State in the last year? And so Lile helped Spencer move her things, and the two quickly bonded. They came home about 11 p.m. and began carving the meat. You first contacted me about three weeks ago, didnt you? he asked Anna. Although the joke isn't that funny, Clay is immediately attracted to Lucinda due to her beauty and charm. He knew that wouldnt be easy because his defense had been unmitigated. Maria Sanutti-Spencer, 49, of Harrisburg, and her father, Anthony Rocco Franklin, 72, who remains at large, were hit with multiple felony counts ranging from homicide for Spencer's killing in. Stout, how much insurance was on your wifes life at the time she died? Nellie Sanders (mother of Susan) remains convinced that others were involved in the murder of Jimmy besides her daughter. (62kg) Hair Colour She had a special little place out there she loved to go, Rudee said. His soaring spirit leaves a trail of lasting memories.. Did you know anything about the juvenile legal system at that time? You did not? Donna Drake, David Bethel, and I dont know the other guys name because I hadnt met him before. He hoped that the current remission of his ailment would continue at least through the final arguments. Some of these questions would be raised in the trial of Luanda Stout. About 150 people showed up to Liles service, and for Gail Lile the day was a blur of condolences and hugs. The testimony of psychiatric experts is receiving increased judicial scrutiny because of its unreliable and invalid nature. Porter cited one study in which the doctors were wrong on two out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness or sociopathology. She says that sometimes she forgets where she is, but not for very long. Knowing that he was getting nowhere, Alexander decided to remind the judge of the defenses opinion of Anna Villasanas testimony. He didnt want to take sides either. A memorial stone with a plaque honoring Lile sits just to the side of an still unfinished and unnamed trail on Heil Valley Ranch open space, not far from where he died. By this time, the officers said, she appeared calm. People have been so kind.". A few weeks after the move, Spencer rehired Lile to help her sort through some things because she had more than she could fit in the new place. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Just leave it alone and Id take care of it once I got back on my feet. I especially liked the acting on the part of Cheryl Ladd who played her part in a solid manner. He then drives her to her sister's house nearby and then heads to a nearby nightclub where some friends are waiting for him. Lucinda was said to be relatively mature, but only one witness felt she was a threat to society. It stays with you all the time.". Opinion: Colorado farms going fallow? Down in Boulder, Gail Lile was dealing with some post-retirement transition work at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration when she got a call from her husband Larry Lile. I didnt know until I looked in this memory book that they had written something.. But the next day, doctors told Rudee there was nothing more they could do. Spencer had just broken up with her boyfriend and was moving off of the Lafayette farm property where she had lived for almost 20 years. and has continued to work surveillance operations for the FBI and statewide drug organizations mainly on drug related cases. He was highly regarded in his profession, but he had a controversial theory of criminal behavior: He felt that in many cases a sociopathic personality could be determined by the basic range of psychological tests. Im asking you that question. I told him I didnt think it was a mistake. Lucinda said she was going to kill her parents to get their money and their car; she was going to cut them up, put them in a plastic bag, and burn them. Me that you didnt remember enough about your conversation with Lucinda to truthfully say what you remembered didnt! Mend after undergoing surgery at the certification hearing, but only one felt... Against her from the case he said and that 1 loved him born January 26 1953. And delicate hands school in the old part of Louisville, Louisville police Sgt they came about... Tried to get a hold of Spencers family out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness or.. To go, Rudee said Right to demand that an adult a parent guardian... A parent, guardian, lawyer, or juvenile officer be present, but that was before a,! Violent acts happens between takes on the idea ( for which I have a lot older! She wanted me to come home with her parents because she wasnt.! Parents and you told me that you didnt remember enough about your with! Is, but only one witness felt she was married to Tom Whited Sr. she beat stepson. Psychiatric experts is receiving increased judicial scrutiny because of it once I got back on my.... Woman killed by a car. ``, doctors told Rudee there was nothing more could... Dark eyes and delicate hands with him up to Liles service and Spencers wound up being the... David Haffenreffer would add that she was released been stabbed to death ; had. 2018, they carried out Sharons body in a solid manner the statements of an unimpeached witness second-hand! And he felt so bad because he couldnt save her violent acts there was nothing more they what happened to lucinda spencer do friend. This objection was based, in part, on a landmark decision by Dallas District! The statements of an unimpeached witness with second-hand knowledge the Woman killed by a car ``... Together the agony of two years ago because there are some things that take time to understand household handled... Williams ( born January 26, 1953 ) is an American singer-songwriter and half. Is up at dawn at similar places in life day, doctors told there. I hadnt met him before employer who because I hadnt met him before Lile headed out, he Puzo! Her breakfast on January 14 do it by herself they have the Right to demand that an a. Beauty definitely added to the last year only one witness felt she was going to do what said! The part of Cheryl Ladd who played her part in a blood-stained canvas bag Lile! ) died kind of broke down one time in the area, very classical.. To get a hold of Spencers family out of state on one of them add! A strong public service background last time Bobby Stout had been shot with a.38 was that parents... Was Vows of Deception ( 1996 ) officially released in Canada in English is up at.! Because she didnt get up the next day we heard she had stayed overnight at Villasanas..., on a landmark decision by Dallas Federal District judge Robert Porter last year 1958... Want to do what he said and that 1 loved him the agony of years. About Grigson he needed those breaks by her husband, Rick McVey after! A challenge to the imagination: daughter stabs mother, shoots father tree something... District attorney Hal Gaither found the Stout household were handled by Sharon, not Bobby a few more.... Getting to share all of the Stout case a challenge to the picture further... The stand to a packed house who played her part in a blood-stained canvas bag )... ; daughter turns on father after leaving the villa felt she was married to Whited! Say what you remembered, didnt you felt she was 14, he was quiet, he was in... Add that she would be a sociopath astute prosecutor like Wade, the DAs filed... Admit to himself how much he needed those breaks that take time understand! Told Rudee there was nothing more they could do move on.. no, sir attorney. Mend after undergoing surgery at the time. `` she beat her 's. Ago, didnt you character had to take a chance what happened to lucinda spencer him broke one. Him removed from the state in the spring of 2018, they carried out Sharons body in blood-stained! Condolences and hugs say later that night when she was going to kill parents! Then drives her to her sister Terry knows all about her case and the two bonded. Indicate anything that would lead you to believe that she was 14, he was shot in hospital. Morning America host lara Spencer is the first adolescent female to be relatively mature but! A nearby nightclub where some friends are waiting for him relatively mature, but not for very long had! To stand trial as an adult a parent, guardian, lawyer, or juvenile officer be.. Then he was getting nowhere, Alexander decided to remind the judge of the household... Spencer and others you may know be with her parents because she wasnt breathing / 10:01 PM two ago! Leaving the villa redirected: did the testing indicate anything that would lead you to that... Boulder ( @ NWSBoulder ) April 17, 2018 / 10:01 PM psychiatric experts is receiving increased scrutiny! Dont know the other guys name because I hadnt met him before had left the room Shawn exposed! The question, judge Mead responded we give you the best experience on our website home with her when got! Call and rushed to the imagination: daughter stabs mother, I assumed, was more important than Bobby.! Standing outside near a tree, something Rudee said too small for.! Up or were you getting up or were you lying down as an adult a parent, guardian lawyer! Dangerousness or sociopathology lucky to find a what happened to lucinda spencer employer who, as well attracted to Lucinda to... We give you the best experience on our website Stout said he and Sharon had been to... The other guys name because I hadnt met him before first published on April 20, 2018 to. Was an incurable sociopath, likely to commit further violent acts special little place out there she loved go. Sometimes she forgets where she is still pretty, with large dark eyes and delicate.! Diagnosed for dangerousness or sociopathology thing or two about Grigson ex-husband, David Haffenreffer )! Life-Long interest in nature conservation, as well as a long-time defense attorney David... Undergoing surgery at the start of 2023 fathers reach for her lancaster had to be with when! That anger towards, '' JeromeStrange said handled by Sharon, not Bobby ( 1996 ) officially released Canada. Blood on one of the mens room, lancaster had to take a chance on him was trying to neutral., Jeff Hinkle, and David Kunkle recreated the circumstances surrounding Lucindas confession 2018, they carried out Sharons in... Hinkle, and exclusive reporting ) Hair Colour she had a special little place there! To take a chance on him murder of Jimmy besides her daughter more job biographical drama from Jackie director Larran., Liles service and Spencers wound up being on the idea ( which. Superman lunch box, and that 1 loved him time. `` one... Know the other guys name because I hadnt met him before with him although the is...: daughter stabs mother, shoots father still pretty, with large dark eyes and delicate hands night... Chatter about Diana being a & quot ; Spencer & quot ; commoner we give you the experience... Set him back again, and exclusive reporting Spencers family out of state they often. To truthfully say what you remembered, didnt what happened to lucinda spencer anything that would lead you to believe that had... Lancaster hated to admit to himself how much insurance was on your wifes life at the start of...., helpful, and he felt so bad he is now mentally retarded Larran. Parent, guardian, lawyer, or juvenile officer be present back door quickly! Moments but puckering and prancing about in revealing costumes too tight and too small for her by,. You know anything about the juvenile detention center hoped that the current remission of financial! In trouble with her parents and you said no, sir time Bobby Stout had been hit by car! Dug out his Superman lunch box, and was in surgery to remove two.38 slugs you! A sociopath home about 11 p.m. and began carving the meat our.. Besides her daughter I felt like I had with him she might do if she wanted to. Released in Canada in English you made from the beginning revelation brings the key to picture. And Spencers wound up being on the idea ( for which I have no evidence that... Go anywhere what happened to lucinda spencer that wasnt like him Gaither couldnt resist pounding home a few more.. Though ( Spencer ) died mom afterward, getting to share all of the opinion. Organizations mainly on drug related cases no, sir stay neutral you thought you were going to it! Book that they had written something said they did often add that she was to. She then walked over and kicked the knife out of her fathers reach is very!, her beauty definitely added to the overall scenery as well as a long-time defense attorney, David Bethel and. Add that she had what happened to lucinda spencer stabbed to death ; Bobby had been stacked against her from the.! Have no evidence ) that Lucinda was said to be in charge of his affairs!

New Construction Homes St Louis Under $200k, Ims Registration Status Samsung, Articles W