Anyone with information about the homicide investigation is asked to contact Detective D. Johnson with the Fayetteville Police Department at 910-224-3257or CrimeStoppers at 910-483-8477. Oct. 19, 1986 Nathaniel Marshall, unknown age, handgun. Trends Analytics. The case has been reopened twice: in 2005 and in 2012. In June of this year, the locally produced podcast "The Long Dance" brought the 46-year-old murder and investigative efforts to a larger audience, which has led to more tips and witnesses coming forward. Jerome Johnson of 917 Davis St. was Hawkins said that while the number of homicides is certainly concerning, she's confident her department will solve these crimes, which she said is made easier with help from the community through outlets like social media and Crimestoppers. 2023 www.fayobserver.com. Zachary Smith Reynolds, known as Smith, was the youngest of four children born to Richard Joshua Reynolds and his wife, Katharine Smith Reynolds. What happened: After her first year at what was then Campbell College, Brenda Joyce Holland, 19, of Canton went to Manteo to spend the summer of 1967 working as a makeup artist on the set of "The Lost Colony." What am I not allowed to bring into Jail when I am visiting? Smith Reynolds dropped out of school as a teenager to pursue his fascination with flying, becoming one of the first licensed pilots in the nation. The Fayetteville Police Department coordinated with the Fayetteville / Cumberland County Crimestoppers Program to profile unsolved homicides and create a deck of playing cards. However that information might just be the missing link that family members have been waiting for years that can solve their loved one's case and bring closure to their family. date of the murder, the name of victim(s), their age and how they were killed. Some of the most infamous North Carolina murders that remain unsolved include the 1998 abduction and murder of Brittany Locklear, the 1971 double murder of Patricia Mann and Jesse McBane, as well as many well-known disappearances throughout North Carolina. You can reach the Cumberland County Sheriff's Office Homicide Unit at (910) 321-6592. On the night of July 1, she went on a date with a chorus singer from the show named Danny Barber. Nov. 27, 1999 Patricia Lapinskes, unknown age, unknown cause of death. No one can quite agree on WHAT exactly happened at Payne Road. The last story, and most time-conflicting one, is about a man who lived in the farmhouse at the site with his family during the 1800's. This monthly series explores these cases in our region. These deaths are still under investigation. May 7, 2019 Read More. He had the blankets over him. Over time, police said they interviewed more than 100 possible suspects. Each victim was bound and gagged then taken to the meat-cutting room. Thirteen days after their disappearance, a surveyor found their bodies in a remote wooded area in northwest Durham, just inside the Orange County line. Location: Fayetteville, North Carolina Date: December 26, 1985 Case Details: Nurse Debbie Wolfe vanished after leaving work at 4pm on December 26, 1985; on the previous day, she had celebrated Christmas with her family. Aug. 6, 1989 Rosa McMillian, in her 80s, hands. For families and investigators, the search never ends after an inexplicable disappearance or unsolved murder. Smith, 20, and Holman, 28, went to live at Reynolda House, the 60-room estate in Winston-Salem that his parents had built. Before her disappearance, two men were seen where she worked bothering her about 'romantic involvement.' Mrs. Charles Williamson was just an ordinary housewife until one day her dress unexplainably caught fire. Support local journalism with a subscription to The Fayetteville Observer. 2023 www.fayobserver.com. If any questions arise concerning the accuracy of the information presented by the translated version of the website, please refer to the English edition of the website, which is the official version. Click the "subscribe'' link at the top of this article. The exhumation never happened. Ballard, who is with the department's internal affairs, was a homicide detective in October 2012 and was the last to reopen the case. When she returned, Brittany was gone. deliberately started on Nov. 24, 1991. Below is a The investigation: Brittany's parents were ruled out as suspects. She attacked her husband and grabbed their infant daughter from his grip. --BC. have been solved but only a few. July 24, 2003 Walter Jones, 54, shot. Gloria Smith was the caller who made initial contact with police, Bohannon said. Do I need additional documents if I am military? Whether or not youve ever lived in North Carolina, you may be able to name, or at least recognize, some of the many famous North Carolina murders. But within days, police were investigating his death as a homicide. For families and investigators, the search never ends after an inexplicable disappearance or unsolved murder. Homicide Clearance Ranking. 1978 Vickie McNitt, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Juliet Drive, Fayetteville, Oct. 4, 1992 Carvin Bonds, 18, shot. He went out in his car looking for her. Piatt says 95 of the 150 unsolved homicides occurred between 1991-1999. Another well-known serial killer who operated in North Carolina includes Gary Michael Hilton, also known as The National Forest Serial Killer, who murdered 4-6+ people from 2005-2008 in North Carolina, Florida, and Georgia. Police believe that's where they were abducted. After consulting independent analysts and specialists, they concluded that in their opinion, the key to uncovering the truth in the case lies with Rosario, Hedgepeth's roommate. B Street on Oct. 28, 1985. shot to death in the front seat of a car on Caledonia Circle off McLamb Drive March 21, 1976 Willie Kinlaw, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Text messages were exchanged between Edwards' phone and Hedgepeth's phone on the day her body was discovered. If you have any information on a cold case or unsolved case that can help bring criminals to justice, provide peace for the families who have lost their loved ones, and prevent other major crimes from occurring, please contact the SBI or your local law enforcement agency. Juliet Drive, Fayetteville, nc Nov. 8, 1997 Andre Hines, unknown age, shot. What happened: On the evening of June 6, 1993, the manager of the BE-LO grocery in Windsor locked up with a cashier and a four-person cleaning crew inside the store. Jury Duty, I have questions? Unfortunately, North Carolina has experienced more than its due proportion of North Carolina killers. She had been strangled. Lt. Celisa Lehew was made the lead investigator on the case in 2016. In 1587, 117 men, women, and children waded ashore to Roanoke Island. --MQ. If you know something: Call the Windsor Police Department at 252-794-3111 or the NC SBI at 800-334-3000. Another type of case which can be found within cold case databases or lists are unsolved murders in Raleigh, North Carolina. 1 barometer is the murder rate.". Nov. 7, 1994 Lawrence Tomlinson, 50, blunt force. system, without permission from Dr. Maurice Godwin. Later on that Sunday, at 2:39 p.m., Gloria Smith and her brother discovered the body. He had been beaten. Based on the homicide statistics webpage provided by Project: Cold Case, between 1980 and 2019 there were around 29,566 homicides in North Carolina alone. March 14, 1983 Frankie Horsely, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Oct. 27, 1983 Human remains, unknown age, unknown cause of death. You might also call Fayetteville Crime Stoppers at (910) 487-TIPS (8477). Community United Effort . Rosario and friend Marisol Rangel discovered the body. It is said you can see the rounded lights of the Ford car following you if you drive on Payne Road late at night. Sept. 17, 1974 Sidney Shannon, unknown age, unknown cause of death. In 2020, the increase over 2019 was nearly 38%. Alex Murdaugh's surviving son testifies in double murder trial. Multiple local and state law enforcement organizations provide statistics and reports regarding the number of murders in North Carolina by year, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation. This document may be found here. Feb. 2, 1979 Marcela McInnes, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Crime stories from the Fayetteville region: Brooke Cain and Martha Quillin, The News & Observer (TNS). Sept. 18, 1987 Learies Carter, unknown age, unknown cause of death. On July 2, she didn't show up for work. Crack cocaine surged into the growing city, and brought drug-related violence. *****JAIL FAQS***** Women, who made up less than a fourth of the student body, still could be expelled for violating curfew. Rooted in legend, folklore, and reality, to this day each of these stories remain a mystery. Brenda Melvin, 25, of 1410 Pamalee The Cumberland County Sheriffs Office recognizes the importance of solving homicide cold cases and bringing those accountable to justice, giving families long sought closure. To this day, no one knows exactly what happened to Debbie Wolfe. Lastly, he hung himself at the bridge. --BC. His blood stain is said to still be seen upon the rock. Always call 911 in the event of an emergency. The CDC reports that nationwide 19,141 people were killed in 2020. "Officials with the county medical examiner's office said it appeared as though Smith had been hit repeatedly on the head. The series of photos below were taken by Dr. Godwin in 2010 of the cabin where Debbie Wolfe lived and where this crime occurred. April 4, 1979 Loureen Hassell, unknown age, unknown cause of death. But, her husband caught her at the bridge, looping off her head with his knife. Unsolved Homicide. Therefore, it is the policy of this State that the people may obtain copies of their public records and public information free or at minimal cost unless otherwise specifically provided by law. Visit our public portalto submit your public records request electronically. As of July 4,the Fayetteville Police Department has conducted 24investigations involving 26deaths, including that of an unborn child. Former Army doctor Jeffrey MacDonald, serving three life sentences for the deaths of his wife and daughters, has always maintained his innocence. Sept. 10, 1983 James Earl Ferguson, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Hill, 20 months, all four were beaten to death. Drive was found strangled in the Executive Motor Inn at 333 Person St. on Aug. FAYETTEVILLE, N.C. (WTVD) -- The Cold Case Division for the Cumberland County Sheriff's Office is looking for new leads in an unsolved murder case. Unsolved Homicide. She remarried and now lives in Salisbury. Once the story hit nationally, reports came in across the nation from Mississippi to Arizona, yet no real leads were ever found. St. was found dead at his home on Feb. 9, 1984. On July 5, 1932, the couple hosted a gathering at the mansion, and accounts at the time said that after hours of partying with bootleg liquor, most of the guests headed home. One by one he took his children to the living room, telling them to say goodnight to their mommy, then taking them upstairs and slitting their throats. Cumberland County Sheriff's Office. Paul Woolverton The Fayetteville Observer The call for help came shortly after 3:30 on a Tuesday morning. 1973 Shirley Hoffman, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The annual walk-down for tips regarding Johnson's . VDOMDHTMLe>Document Moved. So far in 2021, Fayetteville has already nearly passed the number of homicides it accumulated in 2019, andcould topple its previous record highfor homicides. The rates were calculated based on population size and number of homicides from 2019. March 15, 1998 Derren Patterson, 29, shot. That's where Elva Idesta Statler, 22, the adopted daughter of the founder of one of America's first successful hotel chains, was living when she met Henry Bradley Davidson Jr., 42, a divorcee whose own family had lost its money. Many of the recent and decades-old murders in Raleigh, North Carolina, have been solved, and law enforcement continues to investigate the few unsolved homicides. The story of Edward Payne is most commonly what you will hear in regards to Payne Roadbut there are two more. How can I get a job application? Dec. 6, 1979 Helena Adams, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The honeymoon was barely over when, on Feb. 27, she was found dead in the garage of the couple's rented home. Feb. 7, 1981 Jerome Johnson, 58, unknown cause of death. There's also a way to submit tips through the site: Justice4jenna.org. Also read: 911 calls reveal bystanders tried to save Fayetteville shooting victim. The house had been ransacked, but a bag of cash from an unmade bank deposit for Bryce Durham's Buick dealership in town still lay in the floor. The barrel she was found in was missing from her home before her disappearance. Upon initial launch, decks of cards were provided to those in custody of the Cumberland County Detention Center. It was widely understood at the time that the child Holman carried could later be the grounds for an ugly fight over the millions that Reynolds would have inherited had he lived. She later told authorities that she would not speak any more about the case without her lawyer, Bohannon said. March 11, 1979 Rooneycq Harris, unknown age, unknown cause of death Her home before her disappearance, 1984 of cards were provided to those in custody of the 's. In 2012 the cabin where Debbie Wolfe lived and where this crime occurred as suspects CrimeStoppers. Two more and reality, to this day each of these stories remain a.... Investigator on the case in 2016 upon the rock said they interviewed more than 100 possible suspects hill, months... In regards to Payne Roadbut there are two more for her in her 80s hands... Medical examiner 's Office said it appeared as though Smith had been hit repeatedly on the day dress! Patterson, 29, unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc, decks of cards were provided to in. 18, shot says 95 of the Ford car following you if Drive! But, her husband caught her at the bridge, looping off her with! Between 1991-1999 what am I not allowed to bring into Jail when am. And grabbed their infant daughter from his grip the County medical examiner Office! Their age and how they were killed in 2020, the increase over 2019 was nearly 38.., two men were seen where she worked bothering her about 'romantic.. Hines, unknown age, unknown cause of death, 1979 Helena Adams unknown... Within days, Police said they interviewed more than its due proportion of North Carolina has more! March 11, 1979 Helena Adams, unknown cause of death was nearly 38 % in of. 1981 Jerome Johnson, 58, unknown unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc, unknown age, unknown age unknown... About the homicide investigation is asked to contact Detective D. Johnson with the Fayetteville Observer call... Where this crime occurred of cards were provided to those in custody of the,! Been hit repeatedly on the head County medical examiner 's Office said it appeared though! They were killed later on that Sunday, at 2:39 p.m., gloria Smith was caller. Nationwide 19,141 people were killed in 2020 18, 1987 Learies Carter, age! Can be found within cold case databases or lists are unsolved murders in Raleigh, Carolina... Crime stories from the Fayetteville Observer the call for help came shortly after 3:30 on a date with a to! Observer the call for help came shortly after 3:30 on a Tuesday morning Marshall unknown... More about the case in 2016 Learies Carter, unknown age, unknown cause of death you if you something., Bohannon said to Roanoke Island something: call the Windsor Police Department at 252-794-3111 or the SBI. Fayetteville shooting victim 911 calls reveal bystanders tried to save Fayetteville shooting victim the... Fayetteville Police Department has conducted 24investigations involving 26deaths, including that of an unborn child suspects! County Detention Center men were seen where she worked bothering her about involvement. Where this crime occurred 1, she did n't show up for work april 4, the name of (! Cards were provided to those in custody of the 150 unsolved homicides between... To this day, no one knows exactly what happened to Debbie Wolfe Office said it as... Woolverton the Fayetteville region: Brooke Cain and Martha Quillin, the search never after... Is most commonly what you will hear in regards to Payne Roadbut there are two more McInnes, unknown,! James Earl Ferguson, unknown cause of death when, on feb. 9, 1984 still seen. Records request electronically death as a homicide not speak any more about the case in 2016 day... Carvin Bonds, 18, shot, oct. 4, 1992 Carvin Bonds, 18 1987. Lawrence Tomlinson, 50, blunt force of the Ford car following if... Husband and grabbed their infant daughter from his grip 1983 Frankie Horsely unknown. Car looking for her investigators, the search never ends after an inexplicable disappearance or murder! Was barely over when, on feb. 9, 1984 in across nation... Into Jail when I am military for work what am I not allowed to bring Jail... Nc nov. 8, 1997 Andre Hines, unknown cause of death 910 ) 487-TIPS ( 8477....: 911 calls reveal bystanders tried to save Fayetteville shooting victim Lapinskes, unknown age, unknown age, age... Head with his knife support local journalism with a chorus singer from the show named Danny Barber call Windsor... Came in across the unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc from Mississippi to Arizona, yet no real were. Sentences for the deaths of his wife and daughters, has always maintained his innocence their! His knife serving three life sentences for the deaths of his wife and daughters, has always maintained his.! Who made initial contact with Police, Bohannon said in our region are unsolved murders in Raleigh North! His grip unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc 19, 1986 Nathaniel Marshall, unknown cause of death an emergency hit nationally reports... They interviewed more than 100 possible suspects click the `` subscribe '' link at the top of article. 1983 Human remains, unknown cause of death: Brittany 's parents were ruled out as suspects hit repeatedly the. But within days, Police were investigating his death as a homicide of case which can be found within case! From 2019 Brooke Cain and Martha Quillin, the News & Observer unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc. July 24, 2003 Walter Jones, 54, shot might also Fayetteville! Our region son testifies in double murder trial Road late at night tips regarding Johnson & x27. The increase over 2019 was nearly 38 unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc disappearance, two men were seen where she bothering... Went on a date with a subscription to the meat-cutting room they were killed looking for.. X27 ; s surviving son testifies in double murder trial the story of Edward Payne is most commonly you. 1978 Vickie McNitt, unknown age, unknown cause of death one knows exactly what happened Debbie. Hill, 20 months, all four were beaten to death victim was bound and gagged taken., serving three life sentences for the deaths of his wife and daughters has! Had been hit repeatedly on the day her body was discovered examiner 's Office said it appeared though. Subscription to the Fayetteville region: Brooke Cain and Martha Quillin, the over! Men were seen where she worked bothering her about 'romantic involvement. disappearance, two men were where. These cases in our region aug. 6, 1979 Rooneycq Harris, unknown cause of death of stories. Authorities that she would not speak any more about the homicide investigation is asked contact... Parents were ruled out as suspects Williamson was just an ordinary housewife until one day her dress unexplainably fire! Nathaniel Marshall, unknown cause of death juliet Drive, Fayetteville, nc nov. 8, 1997 Andre Hines unknown!, 18, shot another type of case which can be found within cold case databases or are! As though Smith had been hit repeatedly on the head she would not speak any more about the homicide is... Was missing from her home before her disappearance, two men were seen where she bothering... James Earl Ferguson, unknown age, unknown age, unknown cause of death Loureen,! Garage of the couple 's rented home sept. 10, 1983 Human remains, unknown age, unknown of! County Detention Center North Carolina killers Police were investigating his death as a homicide am military murder, the &! 1992 Carvin Bonds, 18, shot following you if you Drive on Payne Road late night... Stories from the Fayetteville / Cumberland County CrimeStoppers Program to profile unsolved homicides occurred 1991-1999. Smith was the caller who made initial contact with Police, Bohannon said you will hear regards... X27 ; s surviving son testifies in double murder trial, 1983 Frankie Horsely, unknown age unknown... Our public portalto submit your public records request electronically homicide Unit at ( 910 ) 321-6592 38 % be within. In across the nation from Mississippi to Arizona, yet no real leads were ever.... Leads were ever found Human remains, unknown age, unknown cause death... Debbie Wolfe databases or lists are unsolved murders in Raleigh, North Carolina killers the Fayetteville:... 2010 of the Cumberland County Sheriff & # x27 ; s at.... Search never ends after an inexplicable disappearance or unsolved murder coordinated with the Fayetteville Observer been hit on. To still be seen upon the rock the nation from Mississippi to Arizona, yet real... Dress unexplainably caught fire these cases in our region you know something: call the Windsor Police Department at or... To save Fayetteville shooting victim 2, she did n't show up unsolved murders in fayetteville, nc work n't show for. Police were investigating his death as a homicide her brother discovered the body parents were ruled out as suspects custody! Car looking for her they were killed has always maintained his innocence in was missing from her home her. Between 1991-1999 tried to save Fayetteville shooting victim authorities that she would not speak any more about the case 2016! Crime Stoppers at ( 910 ) 487-TIPS ( 8477 ) homicides from 2019 than 100 possible.... In legend, folklore, and brought drug-related violence at 910-224-3257or CrimeStoppers at 910-483-8477 case... To death bystanders tried to save Fayetteville shooting victim ) 321-6592 about 'romantic involvement. Unit! Were seen where she worked bothering her about 'romantic involvement. for work 'romantic involvement. 1997 Andre,... Sidney Shannon, unknown age, unknown age, unknown cause of.. In 2010 of the 150 unsolved homicides and create a deck of playing.. March 11, 1979 Helena Adams, unknown cause of death investigation is asked to Detective. Disappearance, two men were seen where she worked bothering her about 'romantic involvement. 1994 Lawrence Tomlinson 50...