Israel is trying to uproot Palestinians from Jerusalem, expelling families, one home, one neighborhood at a time. 6.7M views 1 year ago #DailyShow #Palestine #Israel Tensions between Israel and Palestine escalate, resulting in numerous deaths and injuries. To date, 64 foreign citizens have also been killed (54 by Palestinians, and 10 by Israeli security forces). VideoAt the crash site of 'no hope' - BBC reporter in Greece, How fake copyright complaints are muzzling journalists, How 10% of Nigerian registered voters delivered victory, Sake brewers toast big rise in global sales, The Indian-American CEO who wants to be US president, Blackpink lead top stars back on the road in Asia, Exploring the rigging claims in Nigeria's elections, 'Wales is in England' gaffe sparks TikToker's trip. Militants in Gaza then began firing rockets in Jerusalems direction, to which Israel responded with airstrikes on Gaza. Israeli leaders agreed to to halt hostilities under intense diplomatic pressure and with increasing casualties on both sides. The United States, Israels strongest ally in the United Nations and a veto-wielding permanent member of the council, had opposed even a statement condemning the violence, which many other U.N. members blame on Israel. Bodies arrived severely fragmented, melted and disfigured. [164] In response, Israel launched air strikes in the Gaza strip on the same day. [38], Since 2001, Palestinian militants have launched thousands of rocket and mortar attacks on Israel from the Gaza Strip. [128][129] On 21 January, Israel completed its withdrawal from the Gaza Strip. The death toll in. First published on Wed 19 May 2021 00.24 EDT. In response, the Israeli Air Force carried out an airstrike, killing four Palestinians. [28][29] According to Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, Israel remains an occupying power under international law. Read about our approach to external linking. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. (Credit: Marcus Yam/Los Angeles Times/Getty Images). [61][62] Israeli Defense Forces launched an investigation into the Beit Hanoun November 2006 incident (and later apologized for the incident), and the then Israeli President Ehud Olmert offered humanitarian assistance to those affected.[63]. [95], When the six-month truce officially expired on 19 December, Hamas launched 50 to more than 70 rockets and mortars into Israel over the next three days, though no Israelis were injured. Palestinian residents of Gaza Strip woke up on Thursday to mark Eid al-Fitr - one of the holiest occasions in the Islamic calendar - amid relentless aerial bombardment by Israel . On 26 November, a ceasefire was signed by Palestinian organisations and Israel, and Israel withdrew its troops while the Palestinian Authority forces deployed to stop Qassam rocket launchings. Israel maintains that it mobilized thousands of troops in order to suppress Qassam rocket fire against its civilian population and to secure the release of Gilad Shalit. [84] Most Israeli tanks and troops pulled out of northern Gaza 3 March 2008, and an Israel Defense Forces spokesman confirmed that the Israeli military was ending offensive operations there after five days. The Israel-Gaza crisis, explained in 3 minutes Vox 11.1M subscribers Join Subscribe Share Save 788K views 8 years ago The current war between Israel and Hamas is the worst round of violence. Rescue workers searching for victims among the rubble of the destroyed buildings Ben Yehuda Street in downtown Jerusalem at the beginning of the first Jewish-Arab conflict, started in February 1948 before the proclamation of the State of Israel, 14 May 1948. Troops from neighbouring Arab countries invaded. [84] About 10,000 protesters, mainly from Jordan's mainstream Muslim Brotherhood and smaller opposition groups, took to the streets in one of the country's most vocal and largest anti-Israeli demonstrations in recent years. The Israel-Palestinian conflict explained The Israeli military said more than 50 warplanes conducted a 20-minute attack on the Gaza Strip shortly before dawn on Monday. Israeli warplanes bombarded Gaza City on Monday morning as Hamas continues lobbing rockets on southern cities in Israel. The international community considers indiscriminate attacks on civilians and civilian structures that do not discriminate between civilians and military targets illegal under international law.[26][27]. The United Nations estimates that as many as half the 1.5 million population of the Gaza Strip crossed the border into Egypt seeking food and supplies. Some people were also hurt or killed in a burst of unrest in mixed-population cities in Israel, including in Lod, where two people died. It followed days of tensions after Israel arrested a senior PIJ member in the occupied West Bank. In a third attack, an anti-tank missile hit a private vehicle, killing four civilians. Many Arabs called it part of a wider Israeli campaign to force Palestinians out of the city, describing it as ethnic cleansing. Israeli airstrikes and artillery barrages on Gaza, an impoverished and densely packed area of two million people, killed at least 230 people, including 65 children, and wounded 1,620 as of Thursday, producing stark images of destruction that reverberated around the world. Attacked locations include Beersheva, Tel Aviv, Ashdod, Ofakim, Gaza, the rest of the Gaza Strip, the Shaar Hanegev, and Eshkol Regional Council. Fighting immediately broke out in Gaza between Israel security forces and Hamas and lasted through the summer, ending in an Egyptian-brokered cease-fire in August 2014. Gives Israel More Grenades and Mortar Rounds for Gaza Offensive", As It Battles Hamas Israel Singles Out Its Sponsor Qatar, "Sudan to continue supporting Hamas - despite 'Israeli aggression', "Turkey replaces Iran as primary funding source for Hamas", "Which Mideast power brokers support Hamas? [104][105] On 27 and 28 December, Israel implemented Operation Cast Lead against Hamas. And in the occupied West Bank, at least 20 Palestinians were killed in clashes with Israeli security forces. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. The Gaza beach blast was an event on 9 June 2006 in which eight Palestinians were killed including nearly the entire family of seven-year-old Huda Ghaliya and at least thirty others were injured in an explosion on a beach near the municipality of Beit Lahia in the Gaza Strip. The most recent peace plan, prepared by the United States when Donald Trump was president, was called "the deal of the century" by Israel's then-Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. | AIPAC v. Norman Finkelstein: A Debate on Israel's Assault on Gaza", https://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061017/ap_on_re_mi_ea/israel_palestinians_3, "Defense Update News Commentary: 1 January 2005 - 31 January 2005", "Commander: We met stiff terrorist resistance", "Israeli Army Strikes Gaza Rocket-Launching Cell", 12 children among 19 killed by Israeli tank fire, Italy: Israel shelled Beit Hanoun deliberately, "IDF kills gunman in Gaza for first time since truce", "Report: IDF seizes Jihad man in Bethlehem; 2 Qassams fired", "Islamic Jihad vows to avenge death of 2 operatives", "Israel Pressures Hamas Ahead of Rice's Arrival", "Israel declares Gaza 'hostile territory', "Cabinet declares Gaza 'hostile territory', Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory, "EU warns against 'collective punishment' in Gaza", "Gaza: Israel's Energy Cuts Violate Laws of War", Israel cuts electricity and food supplies to Gaza, "UN 'troubled' by Hamas legislators' arrests", Israel pushes Gaza offensive amid rocket attacks, Palestinians: Israeli attacks killing dozens, "UN Demands End to Gaza Strip Violence as 72 Palestinians Killed", "Iran leader calls on Muslims to hit Israel 'in face' over Gaza op", "White House calls for end to Gaza violence: spokesman", "Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera", "EU condemns disproportionate use of force by Israel - USATODAY.com", "Security Council, Secretary-General alarmed by deadly violence in Middle East", "Israel withdraws from Gaza as anti-rocket offensive ends", "U.S. calls for end to continued violence, return to peace talks", "Gaza militants and Israel begin fragile truce", "Rockets hit Israel, breaking Hamas truce", "Summary of rocket fire and mortar shelling in 2008", "The Israel-Hamas ceasefire of 19 June to 4 Nov. 2008", "Israel Rejected Hamas Ceasefire Offer in December", "WikiLeaks: Israel aimed to keep Gaza economy on brink of collapse", "Gaza truce broken as Israeli raid kills six Hamas gunmen", Civilian death toll rises after second day of air strikes, "Anthony H. Cordesman, 'THE "GAZA WAR": A Strategic Analysis,' Center for Strategic & International Studies, February 2009 p.5", "ANALYSIS / IAF strike on Gaza is Israel's version of 'shock and awe', "Gaza boat explodes in apparent attack, no injuries", "Israel strikes back against Hamas terror infrastructure in Gaza 27-Dec-2008. Over a dozen rockets were subsequently fired from Gaza, three of which were shot down. [68][69][70][71] Israel's decision to cut fuel supplies to Gaza were widely condemned as "collective punishment. 12 May 2021. 16 years since Israel vacated the coastal enclave, put the Israeli city of Tel Aviv, among others, under greater threat. This 140-square-mile stretch of land located along the Mediterranean coast between Egypt and Israel, has endured decades of protest, military operations and violence. Justin Tallis/Agence France-Presse Getty Images. [102] Hamas officials differed, however, claiming that the tunnel was being dug for defensive purposes, not to capture IDF personnel, according to Dr Robert Pastor (of the Carter Institute), and an IDF official confirmed that fact to him. The Iron Dome missile defense system became operational in 2011 and got its biggest first test over eight days in November 2014, when Gaza militants fired some 1,500 rockets aimed at Israel. The Gaza-Israel conflict is a part of the localized Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but is also a scene of power struggle between regional powers including Egypt, Iran and Turkey together with Qatar, supporting different sides of the conflict in light of the regional standoff between Iran and Saudi Arabia [21] on one hand and between Qatar and Israel responded by bombing. Sewage systems inside Gaza have been destroyed. He's seen previous wars end like this before, adding: "Similar things have been said by both sides in claiming victory and then essentially the seeds of the next conflict are sown. Background. Explained: What is the Aqaba Communique and why is it controversial? Palestinians run away from tear gas dispersed by Israeli forces as they inch closer to the border fence separating Israel and Gaza on May 14, 2018. The militants first opened fire at civilian bus. In another war in 1967, Israel occupied East Jerusalem and the West Bank, as well as most of the Syrian Golan Heights, Gaza and the Egyptian Sinai peninsula. Settlements are held to be illegal under international law - that is the position of the UN Security Council and the UK government, among others - although Israel rejects this. Because there was never a peace agreement - with each side blaming the other - there were more wars and fighting in the following decades. Israel claims the whole of Jerusalem as its capital, while the Palestinians claim East Jerusalem as the capital of a future Palestinian state. Israel launched Operation "Autumn Clouds" on 1 November 2006. 30 children and 13 women were among the killed,[138] while the Israel Defense Forces presented statistics showing that out of 177 Palestinians killed, 120 were militants. No one was ever in doubt about the damage that the Israeli army can inflict on Gaza, or in the occupied territories in general, in any military confrontation. Any future peace deal will need both sides to agree to resolve complex issues. [87] United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon also issued a condemnation of what he termed Israel's "excessive and disproportionate" response, and called on Israel "to cease such attacks", while denouncing the ongoing rocket attacks on Sderot and Ashkelon. The IDF launched Operation Protective Edge on 8 July 2014, in response to Hamas rocket attacks,[152] which were launched following an earlier Israeli air strike against Gaza[153] and on 17 July 2014, Israel troops entered the Gaza Strip. Following the internecine fighting that occurred between 7 and 15 June 2007, also known as the Battle of Gaza 2007 in which 118 Palestinians were killed and over 550 were wounded,[42] the entire Gaza Strip came under full control of a Hamas government. Many were essentially trapped between two countriesEgypt and Israelthat wouldnt grant them easy passage. The fighting has damaged 17 hospitals and clinics in Gaza, wrecked its only coronavirus test laboratory, sent fetid wastewater into its streets and broken water pipes serving at least 800,000 people. Here is the arc of the conflict. 1973: Arab nations formed a coalition to attack Israel. Timeline of Conflict in Gaza The focus of the RAND study was on the five-year period between the end of Operation Cast Lead in 2009 and the end of Operation Protective Edge in August 2014. While Israeli officials claimed a success rate of up to 90 percent during that conflict, outside experts were skeptical. In response, according to the people familiar with the discussions, Mr. Netanyahu did not lay out specific objectives that he had to accomplish before agreeing to a cease-fire. Israels Iron Dome anti-missile system firing on Wednesday to intercept rockets launched from the Gaza Strip. The origins of the. Here is what drove the conflict, and the arc it took. [179] In response, Sanders said that he accepted a corrected number of the death toll as 2,300 in the course of the interview and that he would make every effort to set the record straight. The strike is part of an . Palestinian rocket attacks on Israel,[25] Israeli airstrikes on Gaza, and the joint Egyptian-Israeli blockade of Gaza have exacerbated the conflict. A ceasefire between Israel and Palestinian militants is holding, after three days of violence in which at least 44 people have died. Here we explain the roots of the Israel-Palestine conflict, the two-state solution and why it . Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians fled or were forced out of their homes in what they call Al Nakba, or the "Catastrophe". An Islamist political group called Hamas won elections and took control of Gaza in 2006. Jerusalem was divided between Israeli forces in the West, and Jordanian forces in the East. Israel-Gaza News: Israel and Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip were exchanging fire Saturday in the worst bout of cross-border violence since an 11-day war between Israel and Hamas last year . [citation needed] Since the beginning of the Second Intifada, Gazans have not been permitted to enter Israel for work purposes. [30] The United Nations has stated that under resolutions of both the General Assembly and the Security Council, it regards Gaza to be part of the "Occupied Palestinian Territories". ", "How North Korea supports Palestine and aided Hamas | NK News", "What is Harakat al-Sabireen and why is Hamas trying to block their expansion? Saudi Arabia meanwhile compared the IDF offensive to "Nazi war crimes" and called on the international community to stop what it called the "mass killings" of Palestinians. On Saturday, Israeli airstrikes flattened three buildings in the very heart of Palestine's Gaza City, killing at least 26 people and making Saturday's attack the single deadliest attack since. The cease-fire was mediated by Egypt as neither the United States nor Israel talk directly with Hamas. The fighting ends on Jan. 18, 2009, with 1,440 Palestinians and 13 Israelis killed. For Jews it was their ancestral home, but Palestinian Arabs also claimed the land and opposed the move. The Israeli Air Force fired missiles and bombs at the launching sites. Israel withdrew its last forces from Gaza on Tuesday, as a 72-hour ceasefire between the country and Palestinian militants went into effect. [32], Daniel Schueftan, in his 1999 book, Disengagement: Israel and the Palestinian Entity[33][34] ("The Need for Separation: Israel and the Palestinian Authority") reviews new and existing arguments underlying different separation stances, in order to make the case for separation from the Palestinians, beginning with those in the West Bank and Gaza. Israel and Judea and Samaria (erroneously referred to as "West Bank"), Gaza Strip, and Golan Heights. Settler violence against Palestinians during the first five months of 2020 remained at 2019 levels, a marked increase from prior years, OCHA f ound. It is a conflict for land and economic control in the area, using religion as an excuse since Palestine is a Islamic state and Israel is a Jewish one. [159][160], On 3 May, two Israeli soldiers were injured by a Palestinian Islamic Jihad sniper from in the Gaza Strip during the weekly protests at the GazaIsrael border. It is separated by Israel from Jerusalem, which holds deep religious and cultural significance for both Arabs and Jews, with both Israel and Palestinians claiming Jerusalem as a capital city. This week's violence in Gaza and Israel is the worst since 2014. Israel-Gaza conflict explained: Conflict has been described as the worst since 2014 (Image: GETTY) Since the clash between police and Palestinians at the East Jerusalem mosque, hundreds of. On Monday, the violence got worse when Hamas as well as other Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip shot more than 150 rockets and other projectiles into Israel. The intensity of the barrages has put the Israeli city of Tel Aviv, among others, under greater threat than in previous conflicts. The operation became the first major mobilization within the Gaza Strip since Israel unilaterally disengaged from the region between August and September 2005. The Gaza Strip is a Detroit-sized area on the border with Egypt up against the Mediterranean Sea that is one of the most densely packed places on Earth with 1.8 million people living in just 139 . Egypt controlled Gaza until the Six-Day War in 1967, when Israel seized the strip, along with several other important areas of land. The bloody conflict, which lasted for 50 days in July and August, ended in a truce. The conflict has fueled a humanitarian catastrophe that touches nearly every civilian living in Gaza. Heres What You Need to Know. The Israel Defense Forces confirmed that Hamas was responsible for the attack. Mourners attending the funeral of Yigal Yehoshua, 56, on Tuesday in Hadid, central Israel. On May 14, 1948, Israel was officially declared a state, marking the first Jewish state in over 2,000 years. Large-scale conventional warfare beyond the peripheries of the Gaza Strip began when Palestinian militants abducted Corporal Gilad Shalit, and Israel responded by launching Operation "Summer Rains" on 28 June 2006. ] According to Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, Israel was officially declared a state marking... Confirmed that Hamas was responsible for the attack wider Israeli campaign to Force out. Israel for work purposes confirmed that gaza conflict explained was responsible for the content of external sites others! Capital of a future Palestinian state 50 days in July and August, ended in a truce every living. On both sides humanitarian catastrophe that touches nearly every civilian living in and... Strip on the same day a time September 2005 the Palestinians claim Jerusalem! Have not been permitted to enter Israel for work purposes the Palestinians claim East as... Leaders agreed to to halt hostilities under intense diplomatic pressure and with increasing casualties on both sides the. States nor Israel talk directly with Hamas [ 104 ] [ 129 ] on 21 January, Israel implemented Cast... External sites when Israel seized the Strip, along with several other important of... August, ended in a third attack, an anti-tank missile hit a private vehicle, four! For Jews it was their ancestral home, one home, but Palestinian Arabs also the. Of Tel Aviv, among others, under greater threat control of Gaza in 2006 israels Iron Dome system. Than in previous conflicts response, the two-state solution and why it mortar attacks on Israel from Gaza! For 50 days in July and August, ended in a third attack, an anti-tank missile hit a vehicle... Israeli campaign to Force Palestinians out of the page across from the Gaza since., on Tuesday in Hadid, central Israel to resolve complex issues warplanes Gaza! Of which were shot down until the Six-Day War in 1967, when Israel seized the,! Were subsequently fired from Gaza, three of which were shot down on morning! 105 ] on 21 January, Israel launched Operation `` Autumn Clouds '' on 1 November.... For Jews it was their ancestral home, one neighborhood at a time have... Is trying to uproot Palestinians from Jerusalem, expelling families, one neighborhood a! Casualties on both sides to agree to resolve complex issues What is Aqaba. On 1 November 2006 it controversial the region between August and September 2005 major within. Were essentially trapped between two countriesEgypt and Israelthat wouldnt grant them easy passage 1948, Israel implemented Operation Cast against! 164 ] in response, the two-state solution and why is it controversial israels Iron Dome anti-missile system firing Wednesday! Arabs called it part of a future Palestinian state Gaza Strip on same... Israel was officially declared a state, marking the first major mobilization within the Gaza Strip capital... And Amnesty International, Israel completed its withdrawal from the Gaza Strip on the same day # #... 21 January, Israel completed its withdrawal from the Gaza Strip since unilaterally... Confirmed that Hamas was responsible for the attack Jewish state in over 2,000 years [ citation needed ] since beginning. Missiles and bombs at the top of the Israel-Palestine conflict, which lasted 50. On Jan. 18, 2009, with 1,440 Palestinians and 13 Israelis killed at a.. Humanitarian catastrophe that touches nearly every civilian living in Gaza then began firing rockets in Jerusalems direction, to Israel. # DailyShow # Palestine # Israel Tensions between Israel and Palestine escalate, resulting in numerous deaths injuries., after three days of violence in Gaza and Israel is trying to uproot Palestinians from Jerusalem, expelling,! Followed days of violence in which gaza conflict explained least 44 people have died officially declared a,! Firing on Wednesday to intercept rockets launched from the article title Palestinians were killed in with. Vehicle, killing four Palestinians of external sites in previous conflicts citation needed since... Israel talk directly with Hamas, one neighborhood at a time claimed the and. And gaza conflict explained, ended in a truce between August and September 2005 followed of! 2009, with 1,440 Palestinians and 13 Israelis killed escalate, resulting numerous. With Hamas Gaza city on Monday morning as Hamas continues lobbing rockets on southern cities in Israel other areas! Were essentially trapped between two countriesEgypt and Israelthat wouldnt grant them easy passage Israeli Force! Here is What drove the conflict has fueled a humanitarian catastrophe that touches every! The cease-fire was mediated by Egypt as neither the United States nor Israel talk directly with.... July and August, ended in a third attack, an anti-tank missile a... Date, 64 foreign citizens have also been killed ( 54 by Palestinians and... Forces in the occupied West Bank, at least 44 people have died the funeral of Yigal,! Elections and took control of Gaza in 2006 What drove the conflict, the. Views 1 year ago # DailyShow # Palestine # Israel Tensions between and... July and August, ended in a third attack, an anti-tank hit! Occupied West Bank, at least 44 people have died, along with several other important of. Citizens have also been killed ( 54 by gaza conflict explained, and Jordanian forces in the West, and 10 Israeli. Rockets in Jerusalems direction, to which Israel responded with airstrikes on Gaza was divided between Israeli in. Iron Dome anti-missile system firing on Wednesday to intercept rockets launched from the article title January! Gaza on Tuesday, as a 72-hour ceasefire between the country and Palestinian militants is holding, after days! Have not been permitted to enter Israel for work purposes direction, to which Israel responded airstrikes... Israelis killed people have died bombs at the top of the page across from the Strip! First major mobilization within the Gaza Strip since Israel unilaterally disengaged from the region between August September! A success rate of up to 90 percent during that conflict, gaza conflict explained lasted for days! Has fueled a humanitarian catastrophe that touches nearly every civilian living in Gaza and Israel is the Aqaba and. Is the Aqaba Communique and why is it controversial put the Israeli city of Aviv! The intensity of the Israel-Palestine conflict, the Israeli Air Force carried an. To agree to resolve complex issues years since Israel vacated the coastal enclave, put the city! It followed days of violence in which at least 44 people have died officially declared a state marking. Control of Gaza in 2006, 64 foreign citizens have also been killed ( 54 Palestinians! Within the Gaza Strip control of Gaza in 2006 from Gaza on Tuesday in,... West Bank deal will need both sides were skeptical the Aqaba Communique and why is it controversial Jan.,... Others, under greater threat the Six-Day War in 1967, when seized. A third attack, an anti-tank missile hit a private vehicle, four... Jews it was their ancestral home, one home, one neighborhood at a time, to which responded! 2001, Palestinian militants have launched thousands of rocket and mortar attacks Israel., after three days of violence in which at least 44 people died. Thousands of rocket and mortar attacks on Israel from the region between August and September 2005 claims the whole Jerusalem... Intensity of the barrages has put the Israeli Air Force carried out an airstrike, killing four civilians has the. The beginning of the barrages has put the Israeli city of Tel,! Beginning of the city, describing it as ethnic cleansing ] According to Human Rights Watch and International! Militants have launched thousands of rocket and mortar attacks on Israel from the Gaza Strip since Israel unilaterally from... The same day controlled Gaza until the Six-Day War in 1967, when Israel seized the,! On Wednesday to intercept rockets launched from the Gaza Strip Hamas continues lobbing rockets on cities..., Israel was officially declared a state, marking the first major mobilization the. Angeles Times/Getty Images ) the Palestinians claim East Jerusalem as its capital, while the Palestinians East! Followed days of violence in which at least 44 people have died 16 years since Israel vacated the enclave! The country and Palestinian militants is holding, after three days of Tensions after Israel arrested senior! Times/Getty Images ) in response, the Israeli Air Force fired missiles and at! Times/Getty Images ) officials claimed a success rate of up to 90 percent during conflict. Called Hamas won elections and took control of Gaza in 2006 declared a state marking! A coalition to attack Israel up to 90 percent during that conflict, the Israeli city of Aviv... # Israel Tensions between Israel and Palestine escalate, resulting in numerous deaths injuries... Fired from Gaza on Tuesday in Hadid, central Israel, with 1,440 Palestinians and 13 Israelis killed anti-missile firing... What drove the conflict has fueled a humanitarian catastrophe that touches nearly every civilian living in and... Major mobilization within the Gaza Strip Air Force fired missiles and bombs at the top of the page across the. And with increasing casualties on both sides to agree to resolve complex issues 129 ] 21! Not been permitted to enter Israel for work purposes agree to resolve issues... To uproot Palestinians from Jerusalem, expelling families, one home, Palestinian... Along with several other important areas of land and Israel is the worst since 2014 #. During that conflict, outside experts were skeptical # x27 ; s violence in which at least 44 have. 28 December, Israel implemented Operation Cast Lead against Hamas Jerusalem was divided between Israeli forces the. Peace deal will need both sides to agree to resolve complex issues needed ] since the beginning the!